{"prompt":"You are comparing an AI-suggested code fix with actual changes made in a commit.\n\nYour task: Determine if the commit contains the essence of the AI fix and provide a confidence level.\n\n## AI-Suggested Fix\n\n**What it fixes:** tanstack-router-e2e-solid-basic-file-based:test:e2e\n\n**Description:** fix(solid-router): key Outlet Show on route ID not match ID\n\n**Reasoning:** The PR introduced `keyed` on the `Outlet`'s `` to fix a bug where Solid's non-keyed Show failed to mount child routes when a layout component used `useQuery` (which internally uses `createResource`). The fix was correct in principle — recreating the reactive scope on route change clears stale tracking — but the choice of key was too granular.\n\n`childMatchId()` is a unique ID tied to a specific navigation commit. It changes on **every** navigation, even when the user stays on the same\n\n**Suggested Changes (diff):**\n```diff\ndiff --git a/packages/solid-router/src/Match.tsx b/packages/solid-router/src/Match.tsx\nindex 73f59a968a..2a011d6bae 100644\n--- a/packages/solid-router/src/Match.tsx\n+++ b/packages/solid-router/src/Match.tsx\n@@ -469,13 +469,19 @@ export const Outlet = () => {\n return router.stores.matchStores.get(id)?.get().status\n })\n \n+ const childRouteId = Solid.createMemo(() => {\n+ const id = childMatchId()\n+ if (!id) return undefined\n+ return router.stores.matchStores.get(id)?.routeId\n+ })\n+\n // Only show not-found if we're not in a redirected state\n const shouldShowNotFound = () =>\n childMatchStatus() !== 'redirected' && parentGlobalNotFound()\n \n return (\n \n@@ -485,18 +491,18 @@ export const Outlet = () => {\n \n }\n >\n- {(currentMatchId: string) => {\n+ {(_currentChildRouteId: string) => {\n return (\n }\n+ fallback={}\n >\n \n }\n >\n- \n+ \n \n \n )\n\n```\n\n## Actual Commit Changes\n\n**Commit Diff:**\n```diff\ndiff --git a/packages/solid-router/src/Match.tsx b/packages/solid-router/src/Match.tsx\nindex 73f59a968a3..294d64e0caf 100644\n--- a/packages/solid-router/src/Match.tsx\n+++ b/packages/solid-router/src/Match.tsx\n@@ -469,13 +469,19 @@ export const Outlet = () => {\n return router.stores.matchStores.get(id)?.get().status\n })\n \n- // Only show not-found if we're not in a redirected state\n const shouldShowNotFound = () =>\n childMatchStatus() !== 'redirected' && parentGlobalNotFound()\n \n+ const childRouteKey = Solid.createMemo(() => {\n+ if (shouldShowNotFound()) return undefined\n+ const cid = childMatchId()\n+ if (!cid) return undefined\n+ return router.stores.matchStores.get(cid)?.routeId ?? cid\n+ })\n+\n return (\n \n@@ -485,18 +491,18 @@ export const Outlet = () => {\n \n }\n >\n- {(currentMatchId: string) => {\n+ {(_routeKey: string) => {\n return (\n }\n+ fallback={}\n >\n \n }\n >\n- \n+ \n \n \n )\n\n```\n\n## Instructions\n\nRate how similar the commit is to the AI fix on a scale of 0-10.\n\n**Scoring Guide:**\n- 10: Nearly identical changes (same files, same logic, same fixes)\n- 8-9: Very similar (same core changes, minor differences in implementation)\n- 6-7: Similar intent (addresses same issue, somewhat different approach)\n- 4-5: Some overlap (touches same area, but different changes)\n- 2-3: Minimal similarity (different files or completely different changes)\n- 0-1: No similarity (unrelated changes)\n\n**Criteria:**\n- Focus on: same files modified, similar logic changes, same bug being fixed\n- The commit may have additional changes beyond the AI fix - that's okay\n- Small differences in implementation are okay if the intent is the same\n\nProvide your score (0-10) and a brief reasoning (2-3 sentences) explaining your assessment.","response":"{\"score\":8,\"reasoning\":\"Both the AI-suggested fix and the actual commit modify the same file (packages/solid-router/src/Match.tsx) and implement the same core solution: replacing the granular `childMatchId()` key with a route-based key in the Outlet's Show component. The key differences are: (1) the actual commit uses `childRouteKey` as the memo name instead of `childRouteId`, (2) the actual commit includes `shouldShowNotFound()` logic within the memo itself rather than in the Show's when condition, and (3) the actual commit uses a fallback of `cid` if routeId is undefined, whereas the AI fix returns undefined. These are minor implementation variations that don't change the fundamental fix—both correctly key on the route ID rather than the match ID to prevent unnecessary remounting on navigation within the same route.\"}","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","cipeFixId":"69e143e2d06fc61ac4bb0246","headSha":"db0a9d85b06f96af64590c245a9c3fc07da542fd","timestamp":1776372790705}